Halloween or Holy Wins? What the heck?
For those unfamiliar with Halloween, let’s describe it as the night between the 31st of October and Toussaint Day.
A pagan tradition from Ireland, Halloween is considered an essential celebration in America, with its costumes and decorations, including scary pumpkins, vampires, skeletons, ghosts, and witches.
Alors, Halloween or Holy Wins? Let’s find out!
Halloween in France
Until recently, Halloween was known in France as an American tradition for tourists and expats.
At school, French children would hear about it during their English classes.
In the mid-1990s, commercial initiatives launched by large companies such as McDonald’s and Coca-Cola changed everything.
Using pumpkins and orange tints in their advertising campaigns, they strongly contributed to making Halloween visible to the French population.
The opening of Disneyland in 1992 also had a huge influence on spreading Halloween across France and continental Europe through its special Halloween theme events.
A line was crossed in 1997 when the telephone company Orange launched the funny “Olaween” advertising campaign.
The campaign targeted the younger population, usually the ones most involved in Halloween.
Halloween or Holy Wins?
Interestingly, Halloween has seen a decreasing interest since the mid-2000s.
Five reasons can explain (or attempt to!) the move away from Halloween.
Reason #1
First, the French calendar does not favour Halloween, as it occurs during the mid-term school break.
Reason #2
Secondly, the apparent lack of interest is visible through the shop window decorations of small stores in the town centres.
After investing in “Back to School”, many shopkeepers prefer to skip Halloween and spend their money promoting Christmas.
Reason #3
Thirdly, Halloween was imported as a product before becoming a popular tradition.
Some people rejected it by calling it a marketing tactic with no traditional and cultural foundation in France.
Unlike in the USA, where children celebrate Halloween from a very early age, the celebration has no past in France and is rarely celebrated within the family unit.
Reason #4
Fourthly, it overlaps with the solemnity of the established Toussaint Day (All Saints’ Day).
A fact that did not put people in favour of it, including several religious leaders.
To talk about the dead and death in France is still taboo; therefore, Halloween makes a part of the French population uneasy as they view it as insensitive to be partying on the eve of Toussaint, a time for honouring the dead.
In October 2000, the Roman Catholic Bishops’ Conference asked in its bulletin:
“How long can this marketing operation called Halloween continue to distort our sense of life and death?”
Two years later, Paris’ diocese launched a counter-Halloween campaign based on a play on words called ‘Holy Wins‘.
Reason #5
Finally, one crucial detail: the core principle of Halloween relies on the “trick or treat”.
In a blog post (no longer available), Les Filles du Marketing noted quite interestingly that the concept of private property dramatically differs from that in the United States, where gardens and entrance doors are easily accessible and not fenced.
One comment on the post said, “I found it strange to come into people’s homes to take sweets from them […], and most of the time, they did not have any sweets for us or simply did not answer the door.”
Halloween is still alive in France but might increasingly become a niche market soon, with only teenagers and young adults happy to celebrate it at school or costumed parties where it seems they might have to provide their treats!
Halloween or Holy Wins: Vocabulary
(f) for féminin, (m) for masculin, (adj) for adjective and (v) for verbs
- All Saints’ Day = Toussaint (f)
- to celebrate = célébrer (v)
- celebration = célébration (f)
- ghost = fantôme (m)
- Ireland = Irlande (f)
- marketing = marketing (m)
- party = fête (f)
- sweet = bonbon (m)
- tradition = tradition (f)
- United States = États-Unis (m,p)
- vampire = vampire (m)
- witch = sorcier (m) / sorcière (f)
Excellent points.
As a French living in Sydney, I’d love to read your take on Halloween transposed in the Australian context.
As you mentioned, it feels awkward to celebrate the death in that way and we do have the Toussaint on 1 Nov followed by the day for the death on 2 Nov. The comment on private property is also spot on, especially as an organised thing. Of course, French people are happy to give stuff to kids but as a one off, say the scouts coming to sell their calendars, kids from the neighbourhood selling their raffle tickets… But that one night where you’re supposed to be on standby waiting for sweet-hungry kids, no thanks!
It feels on the other hand that Aussies are trying hard at getting Halloween right. Or could it be because I live in a suburb where a majority of British and Irish lives?